Harry Potter and the Cursed Child is billed as the eighth Potter story, written as a play by Jack Thorne with input from J.K. Rowling, and directed by John Tiffany. It’s probably the biggest theatrical event of the year, and as I’m a huge Harry Potter fan, one which I had been looking forward to for months. I managed to get hold of a ticket only a few weeks ago, thanks to the online returns email list, and got the afternoon off work to attend both parts in one marathon day. While it was an unforgettable experience, I came out with mixed feelings.
*Note: while there are no spoilers as such in this review – I avoided every review and description of the show before attending as I didn’t want to know a thing about it. If you feel the same way, don’t read this!
I thought the show (I keep describing it as one show even though it’s in two parts) excelled in terms of stagecraft and in terms of the development of relationships between the characters. I was in the second row of the stalls so I could often glimpse how they were doing some of the tricks – the Polyjuice Potion for instance, and the Patronus – but I didn’t find that this detracted from my enjoyment. From further back I would imagine that this would be very impressive indeed: as it was, I still found it magical.
I was very impressed with the cast. Jamie Parker is just wonderful. He IS Harry Potter. His performance was so moving, especially in the second part. One scene in particular towards the end was particularly heartbreaking. Hermione and Ron were great too: Noma Dumezweni was very dry and sarcastic and this really suited her character, while Paul Thornley was very funny and warm.
I loved the character of Scorpius (Anthony Boyle), and while I found Albus annoying at first (the character not the actor, Sam Clemmett) he grew on me. I found Delphine (Esther Smith) interesting at first but sadly I wasn’t impressed during Part II: I found her character was a bit pantomimic.
This play is really about fathers and sons and their relationships. The last scene with Harry and Albus nearly made me cry and I enjoyed seeing how their relationship developed during the play: the same with Scorpius and Draco, and even Harry and Draco. My biggest problem with Cursed Child is the plot: I won’t go into detail for obvious reasons but I didn’t find the central premise of the show believable. One character in particular did something I just didn’t find convincing, which was a big issue for me.
Seeing the show in mid-August, I wondered if most audience members would have read the book but by the sounds of it, they hadn’t. It was a brilliant audience – quiet and attentive when it mattered, applause at the beginning of each part (because we’re Potter fans and we’re so excited!) and at crucial moments. Laughter at the funniest lines and gasps when surprises were revealed. It was lovely to be part of an audience that was so engaged, and not a ringing phone to be heard!
While I have issues with some aspects of Cursed Child, overall I thought it was a wonderful spectacle and unmissable for Potter fans. It was lovely to visit the Potter world again and meet my favourite characters, as well as being introduced to some new ones. This play will run and run: I do hope I get to see it again someday.